feat: WENO5 sum-of-squares beta on uniform grids (cancellation-free smoothness indicators)#1408
Conversation
…ation On uniform Cartesian grids, compute WENO5 smoothness indicators using the Jiang & Shu (1996) sum-of-squares form: beta(0) = 13/12*(dvd1-dvd0)^2 + 1/4*(dvd1-3*dvd0)^2 beta(1) = 13/12*(dvd0-dvd(-1))^2 + 1/4*(dvd0+dvd(-1))^2 beta(2) = 13/12*(dvd(-1)-dvd(-2))^2 + 1/4*(3*dvd(-1)-dvd(-2))^2 Each term is a perfect square — no negative cross-terms, no cancellation. Algebraically equivalent to the precomputed beta_coef form on uniform grids. Non-uniform grids fall back to the existing precomputed coefficients. Uniformity is detected once at init in s_compute_weno_coefficients by comparing each cell spacing to the mean; result stored in uniform_grid(3) and uploaded to GPU.
Claude Code ReviewHead SHA: 7c9660d Files changed:
Findings[Correctness] Uniform-grid beta formulas hardcode exactly 3 stencils — incomplete for WENO7, wrong for WENO3 The new
The pre-existing The non-uniform fall-back path is unchanged and generalises correctly via the precomputed Relevant changed lines: |
…cision The previous 1e-10 threshold was below machine epsilon for real(4) (~1.2e-7), causing uniform_grid to always be .false. in --single builds since FP-computed spacings deviate at ~1e-7 level. Using sqrt(epsilon(h0))*abs(h0) is precision-agnostic: ~1.5e-8 relative in double, ~3.5e-4 in single -- above FP noise in both modes.
…ormulation Algebraically equivalent change shifts FP outputs by ~1 ulp, amplified through nonlinear WENO weights to ~2.3% per-point relative on the most sensitive axisymmetric/acoustic-source tests. Verified via convergence study: ||SOS - master||_inf shrinks at >5x WENO5 truncation rate, both forms converging to the same physical limit. Affected tests: - 059D137F: 2D Hypoelasticity 1 Fluid Axisymmetric - 3E23CB5D: 2D Acoustic Source Transducer Array - 6FE484B5: 2D Axisymmetric HLL - 7A9F4EF4: 2D Example axisym_shockbubble - 7C2FF26F: 2D Acoustic Source Transducer Gaussian - 7E15602E: 2D Acoustic Source Transducer Sine - B2CBB9FE: 2D Acoustic Source Transducer Delay - B89B8C70: 2D Axisymmetric model_eqns=3 - DB670E50: 2D Axisymmetric model_eqns=2 Full local 568-test suite passes (44m, serial debug).
ⓘ You've reached your Qodo monthly free-tier limit. Reviews pause until next month — upgrade your plan to continue now, or link your paid account if you already have one. |
The low_mach test exercises HLLC's low-Mach correction at near-zero Mach, where (u_R - u_L) is fundamentally small. Verrou MCA sampling variance puts the max_dev distribution typically around 5e-8 with a tail occasionally hitting ~1e-7, making the previous 1e-7 threshold flaky. Loosen to 2e-7 to absorb sampling noise. After MFlowCode#1408 (WENO5 sum-of-squares beta) merges, the WENO contribution to the cancellation chain disappears on uniform grids and the threshold can be tightened back.
Codecov Report❌ Patch coverage is
Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## master #1408 +/- ##
==========================================
+ Coverage 64.94% 64.96% +0.01%
==========================================
Files 72 72
Lines 18861 18871 +10
Branches 1570 1571 +1
==========================================
+ Hits 12250 12259 +9
Misses 5638 5638
- Partials 973 974 +1 ☔ View full report in Codecov by Sentry. 🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
|
…or fix (#1403) * feat: add fp-stability command for Verrou-based FP instability testing Adds ./mfc.sh fp-stability — a persistent floating-point stability test suite using Verrou's random IEEE-754 rounding mode. For each registered test case the runner: 1. Generates initial conditions via pre_process 2. Runs simulation once with --rounding-mode=nearest (reference) 3. Runs simulation N times with --rounding-mode=random 4. Reports max L-inf deviation vs threshold (PASS/FAIL) Two cases probe known ill-conditioning in MFC: - sod_strong: 1-D Sod p_L/p_R=100,000 — HLLC xi-factor cancellation (s_L - vel_L)/(s_L - s_S) near sonic contact - water_stiffened: 1-D water shock pi_inf=4046 — pressure recovery p=(E-pi_inf)/gamma loses ~4 decimal digits on low-pressure side Requires a Verrou-enabled Valgrind at $VERROU_HOME/bin/valgrind (default: $HOME/.local/verrou). Silently skips if not found. Binaries are auto-discovered from build/install/ or passed explicitly. * ci: add weekly FP stability workflow using Verrou * ci: trigger fp-stability on every push * ci: remove concurrency group from fp-stability * style: collapse multi-line raise ValueError to satisfy CI ruff formatter * feat: add sod_standard baseline, enlarge cases, run dd_sym on failure - Add sod_standard (p_L/p_R=10, well-conditioned, threshold=1e-13) as a canary that should always pass under any FP rounding - Enlarge sod_strong and water_stiffened from 25→50 cells and 5→10 steps to give Verrou more arithmetic to perturb and raise sensitivity - Run verrou_dd_sym automatically on any failing case: generates dd_run.sh and dd_cmp.py per case, sets PYTHONPATH for verrou Python libs, saves rddmin_summary and full logs to fp-stability-logs/ (uploaded as CI artifact) - Add python3-numpy to CI apt-get and upload-artifact step (if: always()) * feat: add float proxy, VPREC sweep, dd_line, air_water_interface case - Add four new test cases total: sod_standard, sod_strong, water_stiffened, air_water_interface (two-fluid isobaric contact, stiffened EOS) - Feature B: float-proxy run (--rounding-mode=float) measures single-precision sensitivity without recompiling; skippable with --no-float-proxy - Feature C: VPREC mantissa sweep at [52,23,16,10] bits shows precision floor curve for each case; skippable with --no-vprec - Feature D: verrou_dd_sym symbol-level delta-debug on failure; --no-dd-sym - Feature E: verrou_dd_line source-line delta-debug on failure; --no-dd-line - Add --no-float-proxy/--no-vprec/--no-dd-sym/--no-dd-line CLI flags - Remove dead _max_diff() function (superseded by _max_diff_np()) - Update FP_STABILITY_COMMAND description to document all 4 cases and features * fix: add missing air_water_interface case input files * fix: add alpha(2) for both patches in air_water_interface pre_process.inp * fix: add reduced-energy (E-tilde) scheme for model_eqns=2 FP stability Store Ẽ = E - pi_inf_mix (reduced energy) in the conserved energy slot for the Allaire 5-equation model (model_eqns=2). This eliminates catastrophic cancellation when recovering pressure via p = (Ẽ - KE - qv)/gamma vs the old p = (E - pi_inf - KE - qv)/gamma where pi_inf >> p (e.g. water: pi_inf=4046 >> p=1). Key changes: - m_variables_conversion.fpp: scope Ẽ storage to model_eqns=2 only; add explicit model_eqns=1/3 branch (physical E) to avoid fallthrough to Tait EOS for model_eqns=3 (Saurel 6-equation) - m_riemann_solvers.fpp: HLL and LF non-MHD blocks use Ẽ as states with pi_inf added back for enthalpy H; HLLC Block 1 (model_eqns=3) and Block 4 (model_eqns=2) retain their existing correct handling; xi-factor denominators protected with sgm_eps (Fix 1) - m_rhs.fpp: add non-conservative Ẽ source S_Ẽ = -sum_i(pi_inf_i * rhs(alpha_i)) for x/y/z directions, gated on model_eqns==2 and .not.(bubbles_euler .or. mhd) - m_sim_helpers.fpp: igr branch drops pi_inf from pressure recovery (Ẽ stored) and restores it for physical H - m_cbc.fpp: energy flux drops dpi_inf_dt term (Ẽ not pi_inf in flux) * ci: increase fp-stability case step counts to 50 for better sweep coverage * revert: remove reduced-energy (E-tilde) scheme — moving to separate PR * fix: protect HLLC xi-factor denominators from division by zero with sgm_eps * ci: loosen water_stiffened threshold to 1e-8 until Etilde scheme merges The stiffened-EOS pressure recovery p=(E-pi_inf)/gamma suffers catastrophic cancellation (~2.5e-9 max_dev under random rounding vs the previous 1e-10 gate). The algorithmic fix (reduced-energy / Etilde storage scheme) lives on feat/reduced-energy. Until that PR merges, raise the gate to 1e-8 so CI is green while still catching regressions. * ci: GitHub step summary, file annotations, and float-proxy metric in fp-stability On every run, fp_stability.py now writes to GITHUB_STEP_SUMMARY a markdown table with pass/fail, max_dev, float proxy, and the full VPREC precision sweep showing which bit levels (52/23/16/10) fail. On failure, dd_line source locations are emitted as ::warning:: annotations so the responsible Fortran lines appear highlighted directly in the PR diff view. Both are no-ops outside GitHub Actions (env var guards). * ci: remove pass/fail markers from VPREC sweep table The VPREC sweep is a sensitivity curve, not a pass/fail test. Comparing reduced-precision runs against the double-precision threshold marks every case as failing at 23b/16b/10b, which is noise. Show raw dev numbers only; the main table has the actual pass/fail. * fix: move cons.unindent into finally block; use MFC_ROOT_DIR in _find_binary - cons.unindent()/cons.print() were after the try/finally, so any MFCException raised inside _run_case would leave the console permanently over-indented for all subsequent case output. - _find_binary used os.getcwd() which breaks if fp-stability is invoked from a subdirectory; MFC_ROOT_DIR is always correct. * ci: always run dd_line to surface FP hotspots on every run Previously dd_sym/dd_line only ran on test failure, so passing runs gave no source-level instability info. Now dd_sym and dd_line always run, using a sensitivity threshold of max_dev/10 rather than the pass/fail threshold. This isolates the source lines responsible for the dominant FP variation even when the case passes. Results are capped at top 10 locations per case. The GitHub step summary now always shows a 'Top FP hotspots (dd_line)' section, and ::warning:: annotations are emitted for all cases (labelled 'hotspot' on pass, 'FAIL' on failure) so the sensitive Fortran lines are visible in the PR diff regardless of CI outcome. * ci: add bubble_rp and low_mach FP cases; fix dd threshold to use median * fix: bubble_rp pre_process.inp (remove bubble_model); loosen low_mach threshold to 1e-7 * fix: loosen bubble_rp threshold to 1e-8 (RP ODE cancellation observed ~2e-9) * ci: use float-mode dd bisection (deterministic, nruns=1) instead of random * fix: dd_run.sh must honour VERROU_ROUNDING_MODE=nearest for reference run verrou_dd_sym sets VERROU_ROUNDING_MODE=nearest when producing its reference run, then leaves it unset for test runs. Hardcoding --rounding-mode=float as a CLI arg overrides that env var (CLI takes precedence in Valgrind), so both reference AND full-perturbation test end up in float mode, give identical output, deviation=0, and dd exits 42. Fix: use ${VERROU_ROUNDING_MODE:-float} in dd_run.sh so verrou_dd_sym's nearest-rounding reference is preserved, while test steps still default to float mode (deterministic, --nruns=1 sufficient). * feat: add cancellation detection, MCA sig-bits, and float-max checks to fp-stability Three new Verrou analysis passes, each enabled by default with --no-X to skip: F. --check-cancellation=yes (--no-cancellation): uses --cc-gen-file for structured per-line output of catastrophic cancellation sites in MFC source. G. --backend=mcaquad MCA runs (--no-mca): N samples with Monte Carlo Arithmetic; reports max deviation and a significant-bits lower bound: s = -log2(dev/scale). H. --check-max-float=yes (--no-float-max): detects double→float conversions that would overflow to ±Inf; reports source locations from Valgrind error log. Results added to GitHub step summary (cancellation sites table, float-max sites table, MCA sig-bits column in the main results table). * fix: emit up to 3 dd_line + 3 cancellation annotations per case Previously only dd_line locations were annotated (minimal delta-debug set, often just 1 line). Now also emit the top 3 cancellation sites per case as ::notice:: so the PR diff shows a richer set of FP hotspots. * fix: source context in summary, branch filter on workflow, reviewer feedback - Add _get_source_context() to embed 5-line annotated snippets in the GitHub step summary for each dd_line hotspot and cancellation site - Fix workflow on: push: to only fire on master and fp-stability branches, plus add weekly cron schedule (Monday 03:00 UTC) - Fix log_dir to use MFC_ROOT_DIR instead of os.getcwd() - Remove unreachable 'or 5' fallback on ARG('samples') (default=5 in CLI) * fix: eliminate xi_L/R - 1 cancellation in 5-eq HLLC solver In the 5-equation HLLC block, xi_L ≈ 1 near the sonic contact point, so computing (xi_L - 1) by post-hoc subtraction from 1 loses significant bits. Add xi_L_m1 = (s_S - vel_L)/(s_L - s_S), computed directly instead of as xi_L - 1, and use it throughout the mass, momentum, energy, volume-fraction, color-function, and species flux loops. The momentum flux also uses the algebraic identity xi*(dir_flg*s_S + (1-dir_flg)*u_i) - u_i = (dir_flg*s_L + (1-dir_flg)*u_i)*xi_m1 which avoids both the xi - 1 and the xi*s_S - u (normal direction) forms. For the energy flux the star-state term xi_L*(E + expr) - E is rewritten as E*xi_L_m1 + xi_L*expr, removing the E*(xi_L - 1) cancellation. All 162 1D regression tests pass; all 6 FP-stability suite cases pass. * Update fp-stability.yml * fix: loosen low_mach FP-stability threshold to 2e-7 The low_mach test exercises HLLC's low-Mach correction at near-zero Mach, where (u_R - u_L) is fundamentally small. Verrou MCA sampling variance puts the max_dev distribution typically around 5e-8 with a tail occasionally hitting ~1e-7, making the previous 1e-7 threshold flaky. Loosen to 2e-7 to absorb sampling noise. After #1408 (WENO5 sum-of-squares beta) merges, the WENO contribution to the cancellation chain disappears on uniform grids and the threshold can be tightened back. * fix: extend xi_L_m1/xi_R_m1 cancellation fix to all four HLLC blocks Blocks 1 (model_eqns==3), 2 (model_eqns==4), and 3 (model_eqns==2 with bubbles_euler) still computed xi_L/R - 1 by subtraction, losing bits near a sonic contact where xi_L/R approx 1. Add xi_L_m1/xi_R_m1 = (s_S - u_L/R)/(s_L/R - s_S) to all three blocks and replace xi_L - 1 in mass, advection, bubble, and vel_src flux loops. * refactor(fp-stability): replace committed .inp files with Python dicts in fp_stability.py * refactor(fp-stability): unify CASES + params into one list, add _merge helper
Summary
beta) computation with the Jiang & Shu (1996) sum-of-squares form where every term is a non-negative perfect square — no cancellation possible.beta_coefform unchanged.s_compute_weno_coefficients) by comparing each cell spacing against the mean; result stored inuniform_grid(3)and uploaded to the GPU.Motivation
The standard precomputed form for the centered stencil is:
The negative cross-term causes catastrophic cancellation when
dvd0 ≈ dvd(−1)(smooth flow), losing several significant bits. The Jiang & Shu sum-of-squares form is algebraically equivalent on uniform grids but has no negative terms:Algebraic equivalence on uniform grids was verified by expanding and matching all six coefficients against the precomputed
beta_coefvalues (e.g. 4/3, −5/3, 4/3 for the centered stencil).Test plan
./mfc.sh precheck -j 8passes./mfc.sh build -t simulation -j 8compiles cleanlywenoz,mapped_weno,mp_weno,tenovariants):7789B55A B3E70A3A 48D5C130 9090FC4B 677DAA82 9EF5305B 0ACB1F16 E719C5F2 31742FC7 D6415F48